Metal Roofing Types: How to Choose the Right Fit for Your Home

Metal Roofing Types: A Guide to Choosing the Best

If you're starting to research metal roofing, you're probably feeling a mix of curiosity and a bit of sticker shock. Let me guess: you’ve seen the higher upfront price compared to asphalt shingles and now you’re wondering if the payoff really justifies the cost. Trust me, I’ve walked homeowners through this decision countless times, and the short answer is yes—if you pick the right system. Metal roofing types vary widely in performance, cost, and longevity, so knowing the differences can save you thousands down the road. Below, I’ll walk you through the different materials and styles in plain terms, so you can balance your budget, climate needs, and aesthetic goals with confidence.

To put numbers in context, the average metal roof on a 1,700-square-foot home will cost about $18,600, but the full range can sit anywhere between $8,500 and $68,000[1]. Sounds expensive, right? But here’s why so many people still go this route: these roofs regularly last 40 to 70 years—sometimes over a century depending on the material—while shingles typically last 15 to 30[23]. That’s fewer replacements, fewer headaches, and less money spent over the life of your home. Material choice, roof complexity, and even your zip code will affect the final bill, with prices running $4 to $40 per square foot depending on what you choose[1][4].

[[line]]

What Are The Different Types Of Metal Roofing Materials?

Here’s where the real decision-making begins. Each type of metal roofing has strengths and tradeoffs. The right option for your home may not be the most expensive—it’s the one that lines up with your environment, maintenance preferences, and how long you expect to stay in your home. I’ll break it down piece by piece, so you can see how aluminum compares to copper, zinc, stone-coated steel, and what’s often called “tin” roofing.

1. Aluminum Roofing

Aluminum is lightweight, naturally corrosion-resistant, and shines in coastal climates. If you live near saltwater, aluminum will outlast steel because it doesn’t rust like iron-based metals do[4]. In my experience, it’s also a solid pick for hot climates because aluminum reflects heat, which helps lower your cooling costs. The tradeoff? It can dent in major hail storms more easily than steel, and while it’s long-lasting, color options are more limited. Expect it to last around 40–50 years with very little fuss[29].

Advantages of Aluminum Roofing

Here’s the good stuff: you get excellent corrosion resistance, especially important if you’re anywhere near the ocean[4]. It’s significantly lighter than steel, which means less strain on your home’s framing—great for older houses. Its natural reflectivity lowers heat absorption, which has a direct impact on summer cooling bills. Plus, it’s one of the more environmentally responsible choices since it’s 100% recyclable. When properly installed, you’re looking at four to five decades of service life[29].

Disadvantages of Aluminum Roofing

The downsides? Limited color selection could leave you with fewer style choices. It’s softer than steel, so dents from debris are possible[17]. Some coatings on aluminum may need fresh application more often than other metals. And while not outrageously expensive, aluminum usually costs 20–30% more than steel, at $6.50 to $21 per square foot[1].

How Much Does Aluminum Roofing Cost?

For a 1,700-square-foot home, that translates to $11,050 to $35,700 all in[7]. Yes, it’s pricier, but if you’re battling salty air every day, aluminum's superior corrosion resistance pays for itself in fewer repairs and longer lifespan. Over 40–50 years[29], the math starts leaning in your favor.

2. Copper Roofing

Now let’s talk copper—the luxury choice. Copper starts out looking reddish-brown and slowly ages to that distinctive blue-green patina. That natural shift is more than aesthetic; it actually adds to the roof’s protective qualities. With cases of copper roofs exceeding 100 years, it’s one of the only true “lifetime” roofing options out there. Great if you’re living in a historical home or just want something that outlasts generations.

Advantages of Copper Roofing

The look is incomparable, and the way copper ages tends to improve the roof’s character[2]. It won’t rust, doesn’t need coatings, and is naturally fire-resistant[5]. If you face heavy snow or ice, copper holds up beautifully—as proven by landmarks like the Statue of Liberty[2]. It’s also practically maintenance-free once the patina sets in.

Disadvantages of Copper Roofing

Here’s the catch: copper is probably the most expensive metal roof you can buy. Installed, you’re looking at $20 to $40 per square foot[1]—$34,000 to $68,000 on an average home. Some folks may not love the patina change over time, and its high value can make it theft-prone. Plus, it reacts with some other metals, so installation needs a careful, experienced contractor[5].

How Much Does Copper Roofing Cost?

On the numbers alone, copper material costs around $9 to $12 per square foot with installation running $20 to $40 per foot, depending on who you hire[1][3]. That’s huge upfront, but roofs like this often stretch past 100 years[5][7]. Think of this as a generational investment; it might even be the last roof you ever pay for. For anyone searching specifically for copper roofing cost comparisons, this is the top tier.

3. Zinc Roofing

Zinc is the quiet powerhouse. It develops a protective patina just like copper, which actually heals itself when scratched. I’ve personally seen zinc roofs last well past 80 years, and many go a full century without replacement. Its eco-credentials are excellent too—often made with recycled content and 100% recyclable when removed.

Advantages of Zinc Roofing

Besides the long lifespan of 80–100 years[12][15], zinc’s self-healing properties mean tiny scratches disappear on their own[9]. It’s low maintenance, fire resistant, and highly energy efficient. If you value sustainability, zinc is hard to beat since it usually incorporates recycled materials[9].

Disadvantages of Zinc Roofing

The sticking point is cost. Installed, zinc runs $14 to $25 per square foot, putting it closer to copper pricing than steel or aluminum[1][3]. Early weathering can cause uneven color patches until the patina sets fully, and in heavily polluted areas it may not hold up as well. Plus, specialized installation means not every contractor in your area has the right expertise[15].

How Much Does Zinc Roofing Cost?

Plan for $23,800 to $42,500 on a typical home[1][3]. When spread over 80–100 years, it starts to look like better value than cheaper systems needing multiple replacements. If you’re in a coastal environment, zinc might actually outperform others against salt exposure—making it worth the upfront premium.

4. Stone-Coated Steel Roofing

Stone-coated steel is where modern engineering meets traditional looks. It mimics shingles, clay, or even wood shakes thanks to stone granules bonded to steel panels. The coating shields against UV rays, reduces noise, and bumps up impact resistance. Best of all, it carries Class A fire ratings when installed properly, making it a safe pick for wildfire-prone areas.

Advantages of Stone-Coated Steel Roofing

You get the aesthetic flexibility of traditional materials with the toughness of steel. Impact resistance is excellent (Class 4 hail rating[5]) and wind resistance often exceeds 120 mph when installed right. Granules muffle sound, so it’s quieter than plain metal panels. Energy savings are a nice side bonus with the reflective properties of these designs[6].

Disadvantages of Stone-Coated Steel Roofing

You’ll pay about 20–30% more than for bare steel [3]. The weight is heavier, which means older structures may need reinforcement. Also, over time granules can wear away if treated poorly. Repairs can be tricky if you need to match fading colors, and the manufacturing process uses more energy than plain steel—worth noting if you prioritize sustainability[6].

How Much Does Stone-Coated Steel Roofing Cost?

Expect $8 to $16 per square foot installed. For our 1,700-square-foot example home, that’s $13,600 to $27,200[3]. While it sits in the mid-to-high range, the combination of durability (40–70 years[26]) and traditional looks makes it an attractive compromise between low-cost steel and ultra-premium copper or zinc.

5. Tin Roofing

“Tin roofing” these days almost never means pure tin. It’s mostly shorthand for Galvalume-coated steel or aluminum. Historically, tin-plated steel was common, but modern versions are far tougher and more energy efficient. If you love a rustic or industrial look, modern corrugated or standing seam “tin” options can deliver.

Advantages of Tin Roofing

Modern tin-style roofs are light, eco-friendly, and strong enough to resist winds over 140 mph[19]. They reflect heat well and blend historical aesthetics with low maintenance. Compared to true old tin roofs, modern versions cut down noise thanks to better underlayment systems[35].

Disadvantages of Tin Roofing

The name itself is a bit misleading—actual tin is off the market. These roofs are also still somewhat vulnerable to cosmetic dents, and it can be challenging to find perfect color matches for replacement panels over time[17]. The specialized installation pool is smaller, so finding experienced crews may take more effort[13].

How Much Does Tin Roofing Cost?

Pricing runs $3.50 to $18 per square foot depending on style and material[10][13]. Corrugated versions average $10 to $14.40 per square foot installed, while standing seam can run $13 to $18[13]. That puts the total installation cost for a typical home at $5,950 to $30,600. With a 30–50 year lifespan[23], it’s a middle-of-the-pack option that works well if you want a traditional look on a moderate budget.

[[line]]

Different Metal Roof Styles

Choosing a metal roofing type is only part of the decision. The panel style and fastening system dramatically affect cost, appearance, and performance. From simple corrugated sheets to sleek standing seams, here’s how the profiles stack up.

1. Corrugated Metal Roofing

Best known for its wavy ridges, corrugated panels are budget-friendly and structurally strong. They direct rainwater well and are commonly used on barns or sheds, but with today’s coatings and color options, more homeowners are embracing them for residences too.

Advantages of Corrugated Metal Roofing

The biggest selling point is affordability, starting around $4 per square foot installed[17]. Lightweight panels often allow installation over existing roofs. Despite their thin profile, the ridges make them stronger than you’d expect. Installation is straightforward, which cuts labor costs by up to 30% compared to standing seam[17].

Disadvantages of Corrugated Metal Roofing

Style can be a limitation—they don’t blend as well with upscale architecture unless intentionally designed that way. Exposed fasteners increase risk of future leaks and require some maintenance [22]. Add in louder rainfall sounds than shingles and you’ll see why some homeowners lean toward stone-coated or standing seam options[35].

How Much Does Corrugated Metal Roofing Cost?

Installed costs range from $4 to $14 per square foot[17], with galvanized steel at the low end and copper at the very high end. That places a full roof at $6,800 to $23,800. Lifespans typically run 40–60 years[26], which makes for great cost-per-year value compared to asphalt shingles.

2. Standing Seam Metal Roofing

Think of this as the modern designer option. Standing seam panels connect with raised vertical seams that lock out water and hide fasteners. It’s sleek, incredibly weatherproof, and engineered to withstand extreme winds and snow without issues.

Advantages of Standing Seam Metal Roofing

The concealed fastener system is a big deal—fewer leak points and longer service life[22]. It also handles thermal expansion, looks clean and modern, and sheds snow easily in winter. Standing seam is rated for winds over 140 mph, making it a favorite in hurricane-prone areas[19].

Disadvantages of Standing Seam Metal Roofing

Costs are higher, averaging $8 to $16 per square foot for steel[3]. And unlike corrugated, repairs often mean removing sections of panels, upping the complexity. Smooth surfaces can also drop snow quickly, so snow guards may be required in colder climates. Installation requires a contractor with deep experience, which can limit availability in some regions[22].

How Much Does Standing Seam Metal Roofing Cost?

Expect $13,600 to $59,500 depending on whether you choose steel, aluminum, zinc, or copper[3]. While premium, its 40–100-year lifespan[26] makes it one of the best long-term bets for homes where looks and performance both matter.

3. Stone-Coated Metal Roofing (Galvanized Steel)

Stone-coated panels offer the look of shingles or tile with the protection of steel. Thanks to an acrylic and stone granule coating, they resist hail, fires, UV, and noise better than bare panels. They’re also interlocking, which boosts wind protection.

Advantages of Stone-Coated Metal Roofing

They replicate traditional aesthetics but pack in benefits like UL2218 Class 4 impact ratings (hail up to 2.5 inches)[5], noise control similar to asphalt shingles [35], Class A fire resistance[6], and solar reflectivity that can cut cooling costs by 25% or more[31][34].

Disadvantages of Stone-Coated Metal Roofing

Costs are 20–30% higher than basic steel[3]. Added weight requires a solid structural check. Over time, granule loss and tricky color matching for repairs can be issues[5][6]. And not every roofing crew is trained on these systems, which may limit installer availability.

How Much Does Stone-Coated Metal Roofing Cost?

Price usually runs between $8 and $16 per square foot[3]. For a 1,700-square-foot roof, that’s $13,600 to $27,200. While you pay a premium, the longevity (40–70 years[26]) and lower maintenance compared to asphalt mean strong lifetime ROI. Plus, don’t underestimate the energy bill savings from heat-reflective coatings—those stack up year after year.

4. Metal Shingles

If you like the idea of a familiar shingle look but with better performance, metal shingles are your answer. They mimic asphalt or wood shakes but use lightweight steel or aluminum with interlocking edges that make them more resistant to wind and leaks.

Advantages of Metal Shingles

They typically last 40–70 years—double or triple the lifespan of asphalt shingles[23]. The interlocking fit means they can hold up in winds up to 120 mph[35]. They’re also resistant to fire, insects, and water damage, unlike wood shakes. Lighter weight puts less stress on your home’s structure, and lighter-colored shingle styles can cut cooling costs by 10–25%[31][34].

Disadvantages of Metal Shingles

Costs are high: $7 to $22 per square foot installed versus $4 to $8 for high-end asphalt shingles[18]. Repairs can show color differences over time, especially with older roofs. Installation requires precision, so not every contractor is qualified[18].

How Much Do Metal Shingles Cost?

All-in, expect $11,900 to $37,400 for a typical roof[4]. While the initial bill is steep, the long-term payoff looks better when spread over decades. Add in energy and insurance savings, and you’re looking at a realistic return on investment if you plan to keep the home long-term.

[[line]]

What Factors Affect The Price of All Metal Roofing Materials?

Here’s the reality: comparing metal roofing prices isn’t as simple as looking at one number. Beyond material choice, things like fastening systems, gauge thickness, paint coatings, roof complexity, labor rates, and even whether you’re layering over shingles all play into final cost. Let’s break that down quickly.

Panel Profile and Fastening System

Exposed fastener (cheaper) versus concealed fastener (pricier) is often the first fork in the road. Exposed systems can be 30–50% cheaper than standing seam types[21]. But long-term, concealed systems leak less, so in severe climates they’re worth the premium[22].

Gauge or Thickness of Steel

24-gauge steel is thicker and about 25–40% more expensive than 26-gauge, but it resists dents and performs better in windy areas[28]. If you live somewhere calm, thinner gauge might be plenty.

Finish and Paint System Quality

SMP finishes are more affordable, but they chalk and fade faster[24]. PVDF coatings cost more upfront (30–40% more), but they hold color integrity much longer—sometimes decades in high sun areas[27]. If aesthetics matter, PVDF is often worth it.

Regional Labor and Material Costs

Labor averages $4–$8 per square foot but varies regionally by up to 30%[20]. Complex roofs and steep pitches can increase costs by 15–25% due to trickier installation needs[1]. Always get multiple detailed quotes.

Installation Over Existing Roofing

Skipping a tear-off can shave 15–25% off your bill by avoiding disposal costs. But only if your roof structure can safely handle the extra 5–7 pounds per square foot[32][35]. Consult a pro before counting on this savings strategy.

[[line]]

How To Choose The Right Metal For Your Roof

In my experience, the sweet spot for most homeowners is balancing cost, climate, and style—not simply chasing the lowest bid. Break down the decision into durability, environment, looks, and installer expertise. Here’s how.

Balancing Cost and Durability

Run a quick calculation: divide the total installed cost by expected lifespan. That’s your cost per year of protection. Asphalt looks cheaper until you realize you’ll need two or three replacements versus one metal roof across the same time period. Copper and zinc look expensive upfront but win long-term because of their century-long service lives[5][9].

Climate-Specific Material Selection

Near saltwater? Aluminum or zinc beat steel every time. In hail country? Stone-coated steel with Class 4 impact ratings is your friend[5]. Wild temperature swings? Go with Galvalume steel for stability[28]. Heavy snow? Standing seam sheds ice better than any shingle. Hot summers? Light-colored PVDF coatings cut cooling costs in measurable ways[31].

Aesthetic Integration with Architectural Style

Traditional homes tend to look best with metal shingles or tiles in earth tones. Modern homes shine with standing seam in bold or neutral colors. Historical renovations demand close matching and may even be governed by preservation guidelines[35]. When in doubt, request physical samples to see how options look in your actual light throughout the day.

Installation Quality and Contractor Expertise

This is where many homeowners trip up. Even premium materials fail if the installer lacks experience. Always ask for certifications, metal-specific training, and references. A detailed written proposal outlining components and approaches is non-negotiable[22]. Remember, the cheapest bid often means cutting corners that cost you later.

Evaluating Long-Term Value Propositions

Step back and look at the bigger picture: energy savings up to 25%[31], insurance discounts for hail/fire ratings[6], higher resale value[21], and dramatically fewer replacements over your lifetime. All these layers stack together to make metal roofing not just a premium purchase—but often, the smartest financial decision long-term.

Conclusion

Metal roofing’s higher initial bill isn’t about paying more, it’s about paying smarter. Whether you choose aluminum, copper, zinc, stone-coated steel, or a modern take on tin, you’re buying decades of durability, stronger weather protection, and in many cases, a noticeable drop in your energy bills. For most homeowners, that’s worth replacing anxiety with confidence.

When you’re ready, get at least three detailed proposals, cross-check warranties, and ask to see actual roof samples in daylight. Trust your installer’s experience as much as the metal you choose. Done right, this will be the last roof decision you make for a very long time.

FAQs

Can metal roofs be installed over existing shingles?

Yes. If your structure can support the added weight, you’ll save 15–25% up front by skipping tear-off and disposal fees[32][35]. A pro needs to confirm if your exact roof qualifies.

Are metal roofs noisy when it rains?

Not anymore. Modern underlayment and insulation systems make rain on metal sound no louder than with shingles[35]. Stone-coated metal is especially quiet thanks to its granular top layer[6].

How long do metal roofs last?

Steel and aluminum: 40–70 years[23]. Zinc: 80–100[9][12]. Copper: 100+ years[2][5][7]. Stone-coated steel: 40–70[26]. Compare that to 15–30 for asphalt, and the difference is clear.

Do metal roofs increase energy efficiency?

Absolutely. A well-coated metal roof can slash cooling costs by up to 25%[31][34]. Light-colored or reflective coatings are most effective. Bonus: it keeps your attic cooler, which extends HVAC lifespan in the process.

Are metal roofs environmentally friendly?

Yes. They use 25–95% recycled material, last decades longer than shingles, and are fully recyclable at end-of-life[9][15]. That means far less ending up in landfills, and their efficiency lowers carbon impact over time. If eco-friendliness is on your checklist, metal is one of the strongest roofing choices available.